![]() |
||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Riverwalking: Reflections on Moving Water by Kathleen Dean Moore Kathleen Dean Moore's Riverwalking is a collection of essays not so much about rivers themselves, but more about the company Moore keeps and the thoughts that are inspired alongside her favorite waters. Two major themes seem to converge constantly in this book: how can one live well in close relationship to kin, both holding on and letting go? and how and where do nature and the human mind interact? From stories of her father's life and death to a discussion of the painful process of separating from her daughter as she matures, Moore exposes the familial affections that run deep roots into her rivers. Ultimately, being on the river seems to be as much about family as it is about place, and with whom she walks there as or more important than where. But Riverwalking is nonetheless filled with rich descriptions of place and habitat; Moore is the daughter of a naturalist and the wife of a biologist, which makes for an interesting confluence with her own education as a philosopher.
From a literary standpoint, Riverwalking takes some interesting design risks. The essays are ordered such that the reader is brought without a framework across some difficult territory, as Moore presents loss after loss in her life and a quiet sense of desolation grows. I confess that I almost put the book down at several points, for while Moore painted her pictures well and clearly, I wasn't sure that she was approaching any sort of resolution: although she discussed each loss, she didn't seem to grip them to herself honestly, but instead seemed as if she were looking at her life through the abstracting distance of a telescope. But on page 167, Moore finally brings it all together, and, retracing her steps to her beginning studies in philosophy, starts to put meaning into the emptiness.
I explained to Professor Brauner that I planned to write about René Descartes, the philosopher who set out in 1641 to doubt everything, including the fact of his own existence. What had happened to Descartes, I wanted to know, what had he seen, what strange turn had his life taken, that would make him wonder--even as a thought experiment--if his belief in himself was a bad dream?... Professor Brauner looked me up and down... and then he said this: "There is one thing you will need to learn. And that is that philosophy is not about life. Philosophy is about ideas. Life and ideas are not the same." I never doubted him... The possibility never entered my mind that a philosophy professor might be wrong about philosophy, or about life...
And here, suddenly, Riverwalking takes on a revolutionary carriage. For Moore has been carefully studying her life -- true, often with a distracting philosopher's lens, but she has been talking about real, concrete things like daughters and sons, parents and water, newts and stars. The confluence broadens here: it is a marriage of ideas and reality that she is struggling to find, a bridge between nature and mind. What place does the philosopher have when standing in a river? Is there a sort of philosophy that encompasses this wordless and powerful reality, is there a way to get to a place where idea and life are inseparable, or at least good friends? Moore reveals how her profession is often a profession without roots: So the philosophers I met in graduate school wrote about pure, slick-surfaced ideas like truth and consistency, but not about home. Not about landscape or work. "I will consider myself as having no hands, no eyes, no flesh, no blood, nor any senses," and no one will ever "be able to mislead me in anything," Descartes said, So it's no wonder that "the sky, the air, the earth, colors, shapes and sounds" faded from the philosophical discussions in my graduate seminars.It is not easy to come back to your senses after embracing that void, but I think that Riverwalking is Moore's attempt to make that bridge. She does not throw over her intellect or her ideas in favor of her vivid life; instead she lets us see inside her struggle to join mind and sense in one body. And who knows, perhaps that is the same struggle that the planet faces daily: to fuse thought and will and physical place into one earthly flesh, a completely married landscape. Surely it is only our philosophies that separate us from a sense of the landscape, and of our own hearts; in Riverwalking, Moore invites us to watch as she takes some stumbling steps through the waters towards a different sort of philosophy. One that is indeed about real life, the sky, the air, and the earth. |
![]() |
|
Click here to return to the Review index Copyright (c) 2000-2002 by Maia Cheli-Colando The Spirited Review P.O. Box 4916; Arcata, CA 95518 | |